Every morning at 4 AM, our hands shape each bagel by hand — boiled, baked, and finished with the same relentless attention Pancho built his reputation on. This isn't convenience food. This is craft you can taste in every bite.
No machines. No shortcuts. Each bagel is shaped by hand before being boiled and baked fresh.
Top-cut meats, house-made spreads, and the freshest vegetables — every sandwich is built to impress.
Located on 4th Avenue, we're the neighborhood corner where regulars become family.
Need bagels for an event? We handle catering orders with the same care as our counter service.
From our signature everything bagel to the classic pastrami on rye — every item on this menu is made the way it should be: properly.
Pancho's didn't start as a concept. It started as a decision — that if you're going to make a bagel, you might as well make it properly. Every single time.
Located on 4th Avenue in the heart of Brooklyn, we've been serving our corner since day one with the same approach: hand-roll each bagel, boil it right, bake it until it sings, and never compromise on the quality of what goes inside a sandwich.
This isn't a chain. This isn't a franchise. This is a place where the people who work here know your name, where the bagels are still shaped by hand at 4 AM, and where every customer is treated like they've been coming here for years — because most of them have.
"I've been coming here every morning for three years. The everything bagel is the only thing that makes leaving the house worth it. Nothing else in Brooklyn comes close."
"The pastrami sandwich here is unreal. Thick cut, properly spiced, and that rye bread — you can tell they make it with actual care. This is what a deli should be."
"Ordered catering for my office and everyone was talking about it for a week. Fresh bagels, great selection, and the team was incredibly easy to work with. We're ordering again next month."
5119 4th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11220
Mon – Fri: 6:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Sat – Sun: 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Drop us a line — we respond fast. Whether it's a catering request, a special order, or just a question about our menu, we're happy to help.
